My name is Ryan Holiday and I am a media manipulator.
Or, well, at least I was…
I have a different approach today.
But if you’d have asked me just a few years ago how to build a brand from nothing—how to get press, sell books or move products—I’d have told you to do three things:
- Lie
- Cheat
- Steal
Lie
I’d tell you to tell reporters and bloggers whatever they’d need to hear to write about you. I’d tell you to do things like I did with HelpAReporterOut.com, where I faked being an expert on 25+ media outlets in less than 4 months, including the New York Times.
I’d tell you to lie to Wikipedia and edit your own page and pages that can get you credibility. I’d tell you that it’s fair game to send fake emails to bloggers pretending to be a fan advocating that they write about [the business I was promoting].
Cheat
Rules are for suckers, I used to believe. So I broke the unwritten ones. I’d buy advertising on blogs I wanted to develop relationships with. I’d make it all a little easier by throwing some money around, whether that was fair or not.
I’d buy Facebook fans for my clients (2,000 fans at $80 a pop) to make them seem more notable and more attractive to write about. Then when someone would write about one of my clients, I’d put fake comments at the bottom to make the article look popular. Or I’d buy traffic (for less than .01 a click) and send it to the site until the article was the most viewed of the day.
I’d do anything to get an edge.
Steal
Attention is what I was after, so I stole it.
I knew that once you got a click, a user couldn’t exactly take it back, so I’d get it however I could. Time and attention were value resources and I took them from people when they were expecting real news.
Many times I designed elaborate ruses, that while totally fake, generated millions of impressions. I partnered with bloggers to snag attention through scandals, controversies and “news” that eventually turned out to be highly exaggerated or distorted. But by then it was too late, I already had what I wanted.
How could you…
I’d tell you to do these things because they worked. In a lot of cases, they were the only options available. But notice I said “workED.” Past tense. They are no longer so effective.
More importantly, I have also seen the consequences. “Feeding the monster”—the monster that is our online media cycle—is effective only so long as the monster bites anybody but you. Too many of my clients have been attacked by the same reckless and greedy bloggers who I previously conspired with to lie, cheat and steal.
So…where to from here?
Those media manipulations happen every single day and now that I have exposed them, I have some better advice for people. I can tell you how to build a brand better, faster and more ethically. It will not be, however, quite as easy. (But that’s good because if it was easy, everyone would do it)
Bake Spreadability Into Your Product
Inside Amazon, to get the green light to develop a new product, employees must first present a press release to their supervisor. The idea is that if you can’t already see how to sell it to the media and the public, don’t bother making it.
When Zappos produced 58,000 videos of its shoes being modeled by real employees, sales of those items jumped more than 10%. Why? Because now there was something made you stick to the page, it gave users something to share, to visualize and to talk about.
As Henry Jenkins at MIT says about online media: “if it doesn’t spread, it’s dead.” It is so much easy to market your products if you think about what will make people want to share and spread it from the beginning, rather than desperately trying to do so after you’ve launched.
Build Permission Assets
Rank them in this order: Email lists. RSS subscribers. Facebook Fans. Twitter Followers (and depending on your business, plug LinkedIn in there too). It doesn’t matter how small your followings are, a permission asset is the best way to reach them.
For example, I’ve built a small list of people who like reading recommendations from me. Less than 3,500 subscribers have bought well over $50,000 worth of books from this small newsletter.
THAT is the power of permission. Invest in building these lists—with ads, incentives and time and dedication—because they will pay big dividends.
Make Connections
How much time do you spend actually getting to know reporters, bloggers and influencers? If the answer isn’t “a lot,” then how can you ever expect them to promote your work?
Connect with reporters by giving them story ideas that don’t benefit you directly today, in order that tomorrow they’ll listen to your pitches about yourself.
Travel costs to a conference where you can meet many influential bloggers or journalists might cost a total of $500. But the coverage it generates for your business could be worth $5,000–a 10:1 ROI!
Don’t network—make FRIENDS. Develop those friendships and connections for the long term.
It will go a long way.
Conclusion:
This is the future, I’ve come to see. You could even say I’ve reformed. I’m not saying that what I’m advocating is easier. It isn’t. My former tactics were low hanging fruit that I happily picked. But often that fruit sat on top of land mines. I’m telling you it isn’t worth it.
Build your brand the right way. Build spreadable, great products that lend themselves to word of mouth referrals. Build permission assets that you can use long term to reach people. Build connections and a base of friends and supporters who you can rely on to get the word out. This stuff is harder but worth it. Trust me, I’m not lying.
Enter Derek Halpern…
Before you leave a comment on this article, I wanted to let you know that Ryan Holiday has a new book coming out tomorrow… It’s called “Trust Me, I’m Lying.”
I’m friends with Ryan and he sent me an advanced copy of his book, and I can tell you that there are two reasons why this book is a must-read.
First, when you’re building your blog, you can learn how to spot a media manipulator who’s trying to take advantage of you readership.
(When you read this book, you’ll see how some media manipulators go to great lengths to take advantage of bloggers).
Second, you’ll see how a former media manipulator actually worked. He defaced billboards, ran R-rated ads with the intention of getting them pulled, and created “fake news” by “trading up the media ladder.”
(While I don’t recommend you use any of the tactics he shares, you’re better off knowing about them to prevent you and your company from getting taken advantage of).
Plus, the trailer for this book is probably the best one I’ve ever seen. Check it right here:
This trailer was created by the guys over at Simplifilm. They do good work.
About the Author: RYAN HOLIDAY is a media strategist for notorious clients such as Tucker Max and Dov Charney. After dropping out of college at nineteen to apprentice under Robert Greene, author of The 48 Laws of Power, he went on to advise many bestselling authors and multiplatinum musicians. He is currently the director of marketing at American Apparel, where his work is internationally known. His campaigns have been used as case studies by Twitter, YouTube, and Google and have been written about in AdAge, the New York Times, Gawker, and Fast Company. He currently lives in New Orleans and writes at RyanHoliday.net.
If you enjoyed this article, enter your email below to get free updates!

{ 42 comments }
Worth reading article and I hope all the things mentioned here are facts. We can do anything on web….investing, chatting, cheating etc etc
Fabulous – can’t wait to read this book!
Very interesting….
Ryan,
A reformed media manipulator. Bravo! Loved the article, the advice was relevant and the trailer for your book was righteous.
P.S. I’ve already taken action on one suggestion.
Only the Best,
Les Dossey
The Man’s Man Coach
OK… so, a person who engaged in unethical behavior made tons of money by engaging in said behavior, and now is going to make tons of money by “exposing” the same behavior. Why am I suddenly thinking of Paula Deen? Still, I’ll give it a read – forewarned, and all that.
The book is a good read for sure… It’s a fast and easy read too.
This is going to sound pretentious but I would have made a lot more money keeping my mouth shutting and doing what I do behind than scenes than I could ever hope to make from this book. Nobody writes books to get rich and even though I got a big advance, that money was not life changing considering my career. I could very easily have continued to pull in the same mid-five to even six-figure marketing gigs without ever putting my name out there.
I chose to expose this because it mattered to me more than that.
Hi Ryan, I’m with you on the permission based marketing. That is really one of the biggest keys.
I no virtually nothing about forming friendships with journalists and only a little about forming them with other bloggers.
Thanks for your informative article.
I bet you know more than you think. It’s just simple networking: add value, be cool and reach out!
interesting stuff – will read the book!
Great article – Even greater book trailer. I like the concept of “making friends, versus just networking”. Thanks.
This is the most useless piece of hogwash I’ve ever read. I’m fine with Ryan Holiday’s attention seeking with his book about his trip to morals rehab. But I’m insulted by him telling me to be good and do it the “right” way. Screw that. I’ve been good all my life and I want to be a little bad. Ryan Holiday advising us to use proper channels to get traffic is like Mitt Romney telling us to do honest labor to get rich. This is precisely the kind of lies that I am sick of. Marketers are so often liars and hypocrites.
I am with you. I am amazed that people here this this is so great. Instead of being impressed, I am creeped out that this website condones the bad behavior.
If I didn’t think some people would want to be bad, I wouldn’t have written explicit instructions for how to do that in my book. I am just advising that though it works in the short term, there ARE consequences.
You are the product of your s/Source … whatever “that” may be … and you can’t escape the “consequences”.
B.S. “in” = B.S. “out”.
How long do you want to live, and how long do you want your followers to live? The “human sense” of existence doesn’t last very long … reality is something else – beautiful and is infinite … I am enjoying the journey! You’re invited to enjoy your spiritual journey too for that’s what you’re on right now! Don’t mistake it for the B.S. one!
Derek,
How do you do it? Every article, recommendation and product you write about is fantastic. I know to get my to-do list out every time I hear from you (:
Love the trailer! Gonna check out Ryan’s work.
Highly relevant points, Ryan. There’s nothing like the truth. Love the video.
Ryan,
I am just starting out with my new blog, and my ultimate goal is to build a major brand from scratch? I have 3 existing businesses (the oldest was founded 17 years ago) and the new blog is meant not only identify and promote my quality brand, but to act also as a central hub.
I am impressed that you apprenticed under Robert Greene. I read all his books after a close friend introduced me to The Art of Seduction a few years ago.
What is the one critical piece of advice you could offer to someone like me just starting out?
Thank you.
My main advice would be to know EXACTLY what you’re setting out to do. I’m seeing some vagueness in your goals–building a “major brand” and such.
The key to strategy is to have a precise definition of what you’re doing and what you’re willing to commit to that so you can judge every decision, opportunity and option against that goal.
Exactly. I think marketers and bloggers can learn from other professions. In public health we use “logic models” where you decide the precise ultimate outcome you seek first. Usually we’re seeking behavior change. And really isn’t that what bloggers and marketers are seeking too? Then you back out to figure out your intermediate and short-term outcomes that will lead to the ultimate one. Then you step back to figure out what actions will get you to the short-term outcome. This takes more thought than it appears to do it well. Google “logic models” for some samples. Most people just jump into action with a light connection to the outcome they want, then they’re surprised when they don’t achieve it. That’s not very logical to me! In fact I’m gonna swallow my own medicine and create a logic model for my blog now … totally admit I never have!
I used to have some respect for this blog, but I don’t know now. Look at Ryan’s bio claiming to have gotten all that press. Now that we know he lied and cheated and stole to get the press, the press he got doesn’t mean much to me. I got press for clients by telling the truth.
Please, there’s a clear difference between fake press and then the real profiles of me as a person for my work. One can be faked and one can’t.
negative much?
Love the post…as to networking, all you ever have to do is just BE YOU (the friendly you). The rest takes care of itself (then the money follows).
That trailer is super awesome, I watched it twice.
Good stuff. Reason being: It’s good to know how to protect your brand or a client’s brand from these same malicious tactics. I’ll be picking this up.
Wicked cool trailer btw. Thanks for taking this content public.
Best.
It’s funny that you say that because it’s one of the main reasons I wrote the book. Although the stunts I talk about are cool, I spend most of my time DEFENDING companies from stuff like that.
LOVE this article and your honesty; it’s refreshing. I’ve definitely tried some of the low hanging fruit tactics for my small business clients and they don’t stick. Building connections and developing a base of friends and supporters for your business or brand simply takes time.
Funny story
Easy ways of getting money (or attention) don’t last long usually
Good that you made changes
The only difference between me and anyone else is how I interact with my Reader. Without each one … BOBBblog is just pixels on a computer screen.
I listen when my Readers speak.
shinazy
founder / writer
BOBBblog
Ryan your book seems interesting and Derek hasn’t recommended anything that wasn’t of value, will definitely get a copy as soon as I finish what I’m currently reading. Just days ago I heard of Charlie Hoehn and he mentioned working for one of the clients listed above, have you worked on the same projects?
I know Charlie really well. We’ve followed similar paths
This is news!?! Really…
There have been unethical, amoral people manipulating the media ever since the media was invented. Ryan outing himself as a ‘bad person’ isn’t even original or credible.
Ryan if you were sincerely remorseful and wanted to reform yourself into a better person why didn’t you quietly change your ways and do a little volunteer work in a homeless shelter to make up just a little for all the manipulation you’ve done. Oh but wait, if you did what most decent people do there wouldn’t be any celebrity in a selfless act. Nobody would know about the ‘sacrifices’ you made, you probably wouldn’t write a book about it and you sure as hell wouldn’t make a buck off your efforts.
Everyone thanking Ryan and lavishing praise about his new book should have your head examined. Ryan is what’s wrong with the Internet, he’s the problem and patting him on the back and paying him money for profiting from his prior bad behavior makes me question your judgement as well.
Ryan I won’t be buying your book, not going to recommend it to anyone and wouldn’t even wipe my dog’s butt with it.
Derek, what are you thinking promoting this tripe here? You just squandered a big chunk of the respect I had for you.
There is no such thing as bad publicity.
This statement definitely applies to this situation. Obviously, this guy was/is a jerk, but he definitely knows how to make a splash (and has the connections to do so as well).
Whether it is bad or good, people are gonna be hearing about Ryan Holiday.
I do think Ryan is right in saying that old black hat tactics don’t pay off *as* well as they might have a few years ago. But I still see tons of people doing it successfully — in part because it’s a win-win situation. A client gets a mention because of a fabricated scandal, and a website wins pageviews for a story on it. I think many bloggers and editors KNOW when something smells off, but they don’t have the fact-checking resources; conversely, they may publish with the disclaimer of something being “alleged,” which lets them off the hook while the pageviews roll in.
Also, Ryan, you’re clearly a smart guy, but Dov Charney and Tucker Max are some of the most sexist dudes around. I’m curious to know if “reform” extends to who you take on as clients, too. Because from my standpoint, getting great press about men who exploit women isn’t a winning game.
I strongly oppose the idea of manipulating and multi-folding the readership and believe in original where people will truly follow things which we say.. indeed it is the real thing that can do magic in future…
I’m glad I saw this before I purchased a “promotion” gig over a fiverr. I think I’ll also use the formula O + C = mT (Outrage + Controversy = massive Traffic).
As a mystery writer trying to discover what works for real, I find this both interesting and a bit disturbing. I suspect most folks would probably never think of this. That said, “honest” is NOT a synonym for “naive.” You’re obviously a very bright guy. Congratulations on deciding to help out and putting all that power and ability to more constructive use. On that premise, I’m going to buy the book.
I like the “build permission assets” part. I’m beginning to get it!
Hey; Awesome dude! I love you man!!!
Thanks for showing how it all works…
As a long time blogger myself, I read Ryan’s post here and the comments that followed it. I have to say I find myself wondering how many of these ‘comments’ are real and how many are faked.
This discussion has been fascinating and, as the comments above show (if they are indeed real), there’s a lot of passion on the subject. I think part of this underscores the difference between ROI and “return on investment.” So many companies measure success by a number they call ROI, and many of the more automated or faked aspects Ryan talks about here generate what appears to be success based on “ROI” statistics. But is generating short-term mentions actually contributing anything to the actual ROI of a business, other than getting people talking for a moment? Does getting fake views of a video equate to success? Or having all the family and friends of the publicity team for a company or client “like” a page? Now, the company has the families of their PR team, or their agency, “engaged” with their page, but what good does that even do in the short-term? (And, in actuality, they aren’t even engaged in the page now; they just clicked a button because a friend begged them to.)
I’ve been working with Henry Jenkins, Joshua Green, and a host of others for the past few years on the distinction between spreadable media and “viral media” (for a book that comes out next January). “Viral media” describes getting people to promote something without even meaning to. A Facebook app that auto-generates a message every time you read something, or buy a pig, etc. An email service that sends a little marketing line along with every message you send. Or spam. Meanwhile, spreadable media refers to content that the audience might decide to share, for their own purposes.
But part of thinking about, from the audience’s shoes, what might actually be useful from the company requires a lot of work, as you suggest, Ryan. And it isn’t as easy to measure as taking a headcount…because if you just need some numbers, Ryan points out how easy it is to make that happen. This can be done to create the illusion of success to higher-ups. Or this could even get legitimate views, but not in ways that actually build any kind of longer-term relationship or do either the company or the audience any real good….